Bad News for Sentient Beings
Bad news for sentient beings - I'm failing dismally at lovingkindness. Actually, it's Buddhism I'm failing at, I'm still quite moved by sentience. Six weeks into a three month online Buddhism course I feel myself slipping away from my resolution to stick with it to the end of the course. It's like that moment when you begin to fall out of love with someone. You hang on as if all was well, but it isn't and you can see you're going to have to admit it pretty soon.
Everything was fine when I was sitting twice a day counting breaths, nothing fancy just a bit of concentration. But then came Lovingkindness practice, and the Precepts. Compassion meditation is due any day now, and soon Appreciative Joy and the Four Noble Truths. Oh dear, oh dear. Aside from the fact that even the idea of being nice makes me feel bilious, I just don't think the world will be a better place if I think nice thoughts. Anyway, none of it (apart from the concentration exercises) seems to require meditation, so much as a bit of thought and common sense. The drawbacks of greed, lust, selfishness, killing, lying that the Precepts would have us not do, can all be worked out by a halfway alert brain. My objection to religion is that it gives metaphysical reasons for elementary social behaviour. Buddhism tells you that there are consequences to 'unskilful' actions, Christianity and Islam offer you heaven hereafter for being good. Judaism isn't quite sure about what happens next, but is quite definite about what should happen now. Buddhism offers broad moral truisms where individual thought ought to be. People who don't care about social cohesion have long since stopped being frightened of hell or karma. The secret's out. Not causing suffering is a choice that you have to decide to make.
But this Lovingkindness business seems indiscriminate. A blanket proposition. I can't do Lovingkindness (May they be well, may they be happy, may they attain bliss) but I can manage an ordinary basic respect for life. My heart-centre gets indigestion at the prospect of understanding why stupid, warmongers (say) are the way they are, and loving their humanity while deploring their actions (Compassion). I want to be as angry as a human being should be at people who are causing the death of others. There are, says the teacher on this course, good things happening, as well as bad. Yes, but bad trumps good, just ask those starving to death or being blown to rags. Unless, of course, you stop thinking of particulars and deal in broad generalisations designed to justify our pacifity.
All I was really after was a bit of interior silence to listen in to. A little wilderness at will is what I want. Quite why, all these years after the Sixties', I should have imagined I could take Buddhist theology any better than any other theology, I don't know. No, I am not Leonard Cohen, nor was meant to be. I really must stop coming up with these little projects - as the Poet keeps telling me, they're invariably not exactly what I mean, just a way of fidgeting. The inner woman will have to settle for whatever secular silence she can find.

